Artltdmag is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

The Best Erasers for Watercolor Paper for 2023

Written by Robert S. Brown / Fact checked by Helen B. Harris

Are you wondering about the best eraser for watercolor paper to invest in? You don’t need to exhaust yourself too much. The product reviews shared below are meant to help you get the best alternative that would be practical for your artworks.

Several options from different brands are tackled below so that you can compare them, examine their unique features, and unveil more of their benefits and downsides. This way, you won’t waste your effort, time, and money in the process.

best eraser for watercolor paper

Please don’t overlook the buying tips shared in this post. These guides are intended to help you end up with a smart decision with regards to the most recommended erasers for watercolor papers.

The options reviewed below are mostly affordable; you can buy a suitable item for your artwork needs even if you are short on budget.


<strong>Top-Rated Products</strong>

Top 1

Vanish 4-in-1 4336950576


Top 2

Faber-Castell 127220-P4


Top 3



Best Eraser for Watercolor Paper Reviews

1. Vanish 4-in-1 4336950576 Artist Eraser

This eraser for graphite caught my attention because of its numerous positive reviews. When starting to use it, I noticed that it is good at erasing anything from pastels, charcoal, graphite, and colored pencils. So, I can attest that it is indeed a terrific replacement for illustration, drawing, and gum erasers.

In addition to this, it is reliable in cleaning up sketches without smearing. I am amazed at its ability to leave a nice and neat strip at the end. It could eliminate just about every scrap of graphite from the paper. I can do this without rubbing so hard to the point that the tooth of my paper is already ruined.

I can rest assured that my expensive paper remains in good condition. What is adorable about this eraser is that it is robust enough to erase what needs to be erased, but it executes its job in a gentle approach. Unlike other erasers, it does not leave scraps of shavings all over my paper.

If you prefer erasers for watercolor paper that can guarantee easy cleanup and no mess result, this option won’t disappoint you. While this item is slightly costly compared to other available options sold on the market these days, I didn’t regret spending a bit because it executes its job well.
  • Leave a nice and neat strip at the end
  • Work wonders in cleaning up sketches without smearing
  • Erase anything from pastels, charcoal, graphite, and colored pencils
  • Do not ruin pricey artist papers
  • Strong enough to erase but in a gentle way
  • A bit pricey than other available options
Ultimately, this eraser does not leave any irking sticky rubber-like shaving and is not prone to smearing my artwork. So, I highly recommend it to artists of all levels.

2. Faber-Castell 127220-P4 Erasers

Are you looking for a high-quality kneaded eraser? If yes, then you are probably aware that this brand is one of the most trusted ones. This option works as an excellent drawing eraser that most artists pick.

You can rely on this product when lightening and correcting pencil, charcoal, and pastel work. I consider this product a great purchase for my drawing projects.

Additionally, I particularly find this eraser useful for final drawing touch up and cleaning slides. This is truly a practical artist and drawing tool that every artist should invest in. It is absorbent and kneadable. The kit contains four erasers and packaged in a storage plastic case that makes it easier for me to store them after use.

These erasers are malleable and soft, so they are effortless to shape whenever I need to erase something. I can roll them into a worm, and I can roll them over a drawing to lighten some pencil lines. This makes the pencil lines invisible after painting. As for ease and convenience of use, these are unbeatable.

Howbeit, the major downside I have found on these erasers is their being sticky. They tend to stick on my skin, and it’s a bit annoying that they get stuck under my nails too. I’m still glad that they perform better than expected, though.
  • The kit contains four erasers.
  • Work excellently in lightening and correcting pastel work, pencil, and charcoal
  • Designed with absorbent and kneadable features
  • Great for final drawing touch up and cleaning slides
  • Come with a plastic storage case that allows quick and easy storage
  • These erasers can be quite sticky.
As a whole, these erasers perform well and can lift the graphite and charcoal away without any problem. They are excellent drawing tools sold at a great price.

3. STAEDTLER STD52650BK4 Erasers

I’ve always wanted to purchase top-quality erasers whenever working on my drawing projects. When I began using these erasers, I was impressed at how they could execute their job without leaving any discoloration and crumbles. The erasers are also packed individually with a sliding sleeve and shielding cellophane wrapper.

The sliding sleeve feature is meant to ensure easy handling. Hence, I can carry them with me anytime and anywhere. I can also keep them organized even when I’m on the go. Best of all, they help me clean up small spots without any difficulty since they are designed with sharp corners.

Moreover, I find them easy to utilize when working on my artwork, and I can store them easily after use. Made as latex-free and Phthalate erasers, these options are reliable. Kids can also use them safely. The kit includes a single pack of four erasers. As for the price, these are smart buys.

Besides, I love these items because they can get rid of graphite marks neatly and completely from my sketch paper, drafting film, vellum, and other media. Nonetheless, I highly suggest that you buy these erasers online because they are sometimes hard to find in a local school and office supply stores.
  • Produce slight crumbs and no discoloration
  • Make cleaning up tiny areas more effortless
  • Designed as latex-free and Phthalate eraser
  • Easy to use, organize and store
  • Individually packed in a shielding cellophane wrapper with a sliding sleeve
  • These erasers are sometimes unavailable in a local school and office supply stores.
In summary, these erasers can eliminate all traces of colored pencils, graphite, and crayons without putting so much crinkle on my sketch paper. To ensure exceptional erasing performance, you can give these erasers a try!

4. Prismacolor 73201 Magic Rub Eraser

These magic rub erasers are a brilliant investment. They are designed as good for absorbing graphite, latex-free, and exceptionally erase India ink. They are crafted with sharp edges and corners, so this feature enables them to eliminate tiny marks as well. The peel-off pencil tip is recommended for tiny areas.

What is more, these alternatives are durable and soft, but they can surprisingly erase marks in a more subtle way. So, I don’t need to worry about ruining my pricey drawing paper when I need to erase or correct something. Their compact size makes them more convenient to hold and use every time.

Luckily, these items don’t produce extreme smudge. They are thin enough and offer me more control when erasing small details of delicate artwork. Such products are highly recommended for beginners and experienced artists alike.

The price tag may be more expensive, but they do not disintegrate as other available options. Their durability and superb performance make them a wise investment for the long term. So, I don’t mind spending a little more if the quality is guaranteed.

Contrary to what was advertised, I observed that these erasers tend to leave some crumbs after erasing. Anyhow, this isn’t a big deal so long as they do not produce serious smudge and do not ruin my drawing paper.
  • Erase India ink well, absorbs graphite, and designed as latex-free
  • Durable and soft that erases subtly
  • Designed with sharp corners to erase tiny marks well
  • Help avoid smudging
  • Feature a compact size
  • Tend to produce some crumbs after erasing
In a nutshell, I personally picked these erasers because the sharp edges and corners make it easy for me to get rid of small markings. I can guarantee you that they could work extraordinarily for their purpose.

5. Pentel Clic ZE21BP3M Retractable Eraser

This Pentel clic eraser is highly recommended for buyers searching for extra-long, refillable, and retractable erasers. Eliminating graphite lead marks can be done in a snap if you invest in this item. I chose this alternative because of the practical features that decent quality erasers possess.

In my opinion, their unique features are what make these items a great choice for artists of all levels. Aside from all these, such erasers are designed with a pocket clip that is intended to allow users to carry them more conveniently.

I carry these erasers with me whenever I’m on the go, so I could instantly use them when necessary. If you prefer something that is a great value for the money, you can get this product for yourself. The kit already includes three erasers once purchased.

I could say that they erase sleekly and don’t leave behind the residual pencil marks that other options leave behind. I have no problem holding them and these erasers are straightforward to extend and retract. I consider these retractable erasers as a reliable tool for my drafting and drawing classes.

There is no doubt that these erasers work like a charm for their purpose. Be that as it may, I strongly suggest that you handle and use them with extra care not to scratch your drawing paper.
  • Designed with a pocket clip that allows convenient transport
  • Extra-long, refillable, and retractable
  • The kit includes three erasers.
  • Get rid of graphite lead marks neatly and completely
  • Do not leave extreme residues
  • Must be used with extra care to prevent scratching artist paper
To sum things up, these retractable erasers have helped me make a huge difference in my drafting and drawing projects. I find them as outstanding alternatives for precision erasing.

6. Faber-Castell Large Kneaded Eraser

This eraser for charcoal comes with a double-wrapped blister pack. I chose this option because it does not leave a serious mess on any type of artist paper. The price for two erasers makes reasonable pricing for the quantity. I think this is an outstanding alternative for buyers with a limited budget like me.

I bought these erasers to lighten sketch lines on watercolor paper before I paint. From then on, I utilize them for all my drawing tasks because I love how they work. Apart from erasing pencil lines, I can depend on them to lighten the lines before adding watercolors.

Compared to my previous erasers, these don’t leave behind extreme residues that ruin my art projects. These erasers are designed as quite absorbent and kneadable. I find them reliable in terms of lightening and correcting pastel marks and charcoal.

Not to mention, these erasers can exceptionally clean drawings and slides. In my opinion, these items are 3 to 5 times more efficient than a regular pencil eraser. I don’t even need to spend lavishly for a premium quality kneadable eraser that works like magic for my drawing tasks.

Furthermore, these options come with a texture that is smooth sailing to hold. They work effectively when it comes to erasing what needs to be erased.

Nevertheless, these erasers have a very strong smell. So, I think users who have a very sensitive sense of smell might not find this alternative a suitable pick for their condition.
  • Don’t leave any extreme residues behind
  • Designed as quite absorbent and kneadable
  • Professionally cleans drawings as well as slides
  • Lighten and correct pastel marks and charcoal
  • Affordable pricing for the quantity
  • Might irritate users with a sensitive sense of smell
Lastly, these erasers are unparalleled. They are my great partner when drawing with graphite. So far, they haven’t failed me with my artworks yet.

7. Prismacolor SAN70531-3PK Design Eraser

If you prefer an eraser that works effectively in eliminating light pencil marks without causing any damages to the surface of your drawing paper, this option is a safe bet.

I consider myself lucky for discovering this eraser because it is compatible with most types of drawing papers. Indeed, this is plain sailing to use. You only need to pull off a portion, and then you just have to stretch and knead it before erasing.

I am amazed at how this eraser lightens darker lines when it is solidly pressed against the paper and pulled away. It is very handy, so I find it convenient to carry around even when going outside to get inspiration for my artworks. Compared to other similar products out there, this alternative does not produce eraser crumbs.

More than that, I highly recommended this kneaded rubber art eraser for cleaning fine art sketches. You can also use this eraser for tracing paper, recycled, vellum, hemp, pastel, and cotton papers. When cleaning, all you need to do is to pull and knead it multiple times.

If you do not wish to spend more, I highly suggest browsing these items online. This is because they are priced higher if bought in local art supply stores.
  • Lighten darker lines
  • Highly recommended for cleaning fine art sketches
  • Compatible with various types of drawing papers
  • Do not cause any serious damages to the paper’s surface
  • Straightforward and more convenient to use even for beginners
  • More expensive to buy in local art supply store than online
In conclusion, I have no regrets about investing in this option because it is ideal for cleaning up fine art sketches. It does not cause any damage to any type of paper I use for my masterpiece as well.

8. Mr. Pen Eraser Set

If you need erasers that can be instantly molded into the desired size and shape, this product is worth a shot. Since I started using these erasers, I did not encounter any serious problems eliminating smudges, dirt, and pencil lines on all surfaces. I think this is because these items are adept at absorbing filth and graphite.

The kit contains three kneaded rubbers, three artist gum erasers, and three vinyl erasers. I find these erasers useful in terms of handling any erasing tasks. This is probably why most designers and artists pick this brand for their art projects. Such latex-free erasers eliminate pencil marks more effectively with less mess.

The gum eraser is also meant to clean up dry media. I always refer to this item when lightening and correcting pastel and pencil marks, as well as charcoal. In my viewpoint, such erasers are excellent options for those who love to draw and paint.

Regardless, I noticed a minor gripe on the eraser. It feels like a piece of gum when kept in my hands when I start to sketch. When I try to erase something, it strings and becomes harder to get off the paper. Fortunately, with extra caution, you can avoid this from getting worse.
  • Quickly shapes into preferred size and forms
  • Practical to use for eliminating pencil lines and smudges on all surfaces
  • Highly recommended for lightening and correcting pastel, pencil, charcoal
  • Work wonders in absorbing dirt and graphite
  • One of the top options for designers and artists of all levels
  • The eraser feels overly soft.
All things considered, I find the price of these erasers quite affordable considering the quantity and quality of the product. As for their performance, these erasers satisfy my expectations.

9. iCraft 4087 Adhesive Eraser

Would you like to purchase an adhesive eraser that you can count on tackling various art projects? If yes, then you don’t need to search further. This product is a top option for rub-on blunders, picking up the stray adhesive, or dealing with work surface errors.

Designed as toxic-free and acid-free, you can have the peace of mind that it won’t cause any health issues. I am impressed at how this adhesive eraser eliminates rubber cement, repositionable tape, and residues in a snap. It is user-friendly even for those who use such a product like this for the first time.

Personally speaking, I highly recommend this alternative for all crafters out there. It does a great job of getting rid of lines and areas of dry masking fluid from watercolor paper. It is made as soft, not floppy, yet firm when used.

I use this adhesive eraser for various home and school projects. In fact, I used it for my card making project last holiday season. It helped me clean the glue on handmade cards beautifully. That said, if you’re in the card-making business, this can be a great companion to accomplish your tasks easier, neatly, and more conveniently.

I’m not sure if I made a mistake, but it did not work as expected when I used this pick-up square for my scrapbook. So, I assumed that it might not be ideal for scrapbooking purposes. When it comes to handling my artwork, I did not have any issues with this item.
  • Great option for various art projects
  • Practical for rub-on mishaps, picking up stray adhesive or work surface errors
  • Designed as toxic-free and acid-free
  • Can get rid of rubber cement, repositionable tape, and residues
  • A must-have for all crafters out there
  • Seems not ideal for scrapbooking purposes
By and large, this product is a worthwhile investment for all crafters out there. Correcting numerous mistakes is no longer a problem if you have this adhesive eraser.

10. June Gold 4336950583 Erasers

If you have a limited budget yet opt for a premium quality eraser for canvas, this option is the right match for you. Designed using high-quality absorbent materials, this product shade, correct, blend, brighten, smooth, and highlight drawings and sketches.

I can say that these erasers are the best for heavy and light erasing on the type of artwork that I do. They allow me to lightly erase lines without ruining my watercolor paper. This is why I make sure to have them with me whenever I attend my art class.

In the same way, it works superbly in lightening or erasing pastel, graphite, charcoal, colored pencils, and chalk. When I used this eraser the first time, I had no issues because it is user-friendly. I can mold it into any form I desire. I can quickly clean by subtly kneading the eraser between my fingers.

The only drawback I have is how sticky these gummy erasers are. When I erase something, my fingers usually sink into the eraser and stick to my nails. They also stick on my other art tools and tend to leave a residue on anything they touch. Still and all, they’re sticky, but I am impressed by their usefulness.
  • Lightens or erases pastel, graphite, charcoal, colored pencils, and chalk
  • Designed using top-quality absorbent materials
  • Great alternative for those short on budget
  • Can be molded into any forms
  • Shade, correct, blend, brighten, smooth, and highlight drawings and sketches
  • Tend to feel sticky
To wrap up, these kneaded rubber erasers are very reliable, perform well, and are priced reasonably. They’re easy to use and work excellently for what they were designed for.

What to Look for When Buying Eraser for Watercolor Paper


You need to take note of several valuable considerations before buying the best eraser for watercolor paper.

Here are some of them:


Surely, if you want to enjoy quality, reliability, and functionality, dealing with and buying from trusted brands is the first thing to consider.

A credible brand won’t fail to meet your requirements and satisfy your expectations. So, don’t merely look at the price tag. Make sure that quality is not compromised.

Functionality, Quality, and Reliability of the Product

To ensure that your choice is a wise investment, first read some customer reviews. This way, you can learn more about the product’s features, advantages, and disadvantages.

Consumers who have already tried and tested the product you’re planning to buy can offer you real feedback and reviews regarding the quality, functionality, and reliability of the item.

The Purpose of Use

Before getting an eraser for watercolor paper, you’ve got to know the purpose why you’re buying one. Check if the option you’re choosing is versatile and can be used for various applications.

The Features of the Product

Inspect the essential features that you are searching for in an eraser for watercolor paper. Compare each option and inspect if they possess the qualities you need for the item you’re buying.

Can You Erase Pencil After Watercolor

Yes. To do so, utilize the pencil lines as a guide. Be reminded not to paint over the pencil line. When a passage is dry, see to it to clean up the excess lines that are unnecessary.

After that, you may use an eraser that works subtly on your watercolor paper.


Conclusively, it does not need to be a challenging task to pick the best eraser for watercolor paper so long as you review the important features, pros, and cons of each option.

I hope the product reviews and shopping tips tackled in this article can help you pick the appropriate eraser for your craft. Luckily, there are several options on the market today.

Each option is designed with practical features that make them useful for various art projects. Hence, regardless of your purpose of use, there is one specific alternative that can meet your requirements and satisfy your expectations.

5/5 - (2 votes)