Artltdmag is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission. Learn more

Crayola Vs Roseart | What’s the Roseart Hate All About

Written by Robert S. Brown / Fact checked by Helen B. Harris

crayola vs roseart

Are you a 90’s kid who used to hate RoseArt crayons? In this article, we will dig deeper and find out why Crayola is loved while RoseArt seems not to be favored by many.

We will compare Crayola vs RoseArt and some of their basic art supplies such as markers, colored pencils, watercolors, and of course crayons!

Let’s see what each of these supplies has to offer, its pros/cons, and a whole lot more. To start off, here’s a short general comparison table.

Brand Manufacturing Experience Variety Availability Manufacturing Sites
Crayola Since 1903 Wide range of art supplies Available worldwide US, UK, Czech Republic, Malaysia, and China
RoseArt Since 1923 Art supplies, dolls, and toys No information available New Jersey, Indiana, and Oregon

About Crayola and Roseart

RoseArt and Crayola are two pioneering brands that manufacture crayons and other art materials.

Crayola came to birth in the early 1900s. Since then, it has continued to evolve and produce various art and coloring materials that kids enjoy today.

RoseArt, on the other hand, does produce not only art supplies but also ventures into dolls and toy manufacturing.

So much about history, let’s get to the real comparison of each coloring material.

Read more: Crayola marker materials.

1. Colored Pencils

roseart-crayons-vs-crayola

Looking at the packaging, many love how Crayola puts windows on their boxes so that you can actually see what’s inside. Just like that, RoseArt is overwhelmed only by the design of the box.

But, remember, you can’t judge the book by its cover.

Blendability is a top criterion that one should look at first when choosing colored pencils, and you can only achieve that if the texture is buttery enough.

If you compare RoseArt vs Crayola colored pencil’s texture, unexpectedly, RoseArt comes out to be more buttery. In fact, it produces no streaks as compared to Crayola, where you can see some inconsistency.

As for the colors, Crayola’s range significantly lacks that color vibrancy that it usually possesses on other Crayola mediums, and for this part, RoseArt colors are more lively.

<strong>RoseArt</strong>
Pros
  • Great packaging
  • Sturdy
  • Wide color range
  •  Fairly priced
Cons
  • Slightly dull
  • Not that blendable
  • Produces streaks
<strong>Crayola</strong>
Pros
Cons
  • Poor packaging
  • Might need to put more since colors are very light
  • Limited color range
  • Brittle

2. Markers

crayon-brands

At first glance, you can tell that the RoseArt marker barrel is very similar to the Crayola marker’s barrel. However, the cap is slightly different.

Here’s a fun trivia. If you are a true blue Crayola marker user, you would know this. The bottom of the marker perfectly fits the cap’s head so that you can actually put all your markers together. Check it out yourself.

For the actual application, they are pretty similar. RoseArt marker’s ink consistency is at par with Crayola markers, but not all colors are as vibrant as Crayola, though.

<strong>RoseArt</strong>
Pros
  • Good quality
  • Non-toxic
  • Affordable price
Cons
  • Some colors are dull
  • Not bold
<strong>Crayola</strong>
Pros
  • Bright colors
  • Non-toxic
  • Durable
  • Stackable
Cons
  • Expensive

3. Watercolors

good-brand

One important thing that usually can make or break a watercolor art aside from the watercolor itself is the type of paintbrush.

Surprisingly, RoseArt did a great job with their paintbrush. They are slightly comparable to legitimate paintbrushes for paintings.

Crayola, on the other hand, comes with a decent paintbrush, only that they are not pointed, and the bristles are falling off.

Both watercolors work fine on paper like normal watercolors do. Still, you will notice that RoseArt watercolor’s consistency is a bit sticky as compared to Crayola.

For the colors, RoseArt is a bit darker than the Crayola, but overall, RoseArt watercolor did well with this one.

<strong>RoseArt</strong>
Pros
  • Good quality paint brush
  • Affordable price
Cons
  • Slightly sticky
  • Colors are slightly darker
<strong>Crayola</strong>
Pros
  • Bright colors
  • Vibrant colors
Cons
  • Paintbrush not pointed
  • Poor quality paint brush
  • Slightly expensive

4. Crayons

crayola-ingredients

Among crayon brands, Crayola undoubtedly is the number one globally. There are also special Crayola ingredients for crayon with special effects.

But, let’s see what RoseArt crayons have to say.

There are a lot of negative comments about RoseArt crayons vs Crayola everywhere. You can see them in posts and comments on Pinterest, Reddit, and Quora.

So, why are RoseArt crayons bad? Or should I say, are they really that bad?

I can now clearly see where that’s coming from, but it is okay as compared to other off brand crayons. When it initially hits the paper, it glides almost the same way as Crayola crayons.

But, here comes the negative part. As you go on coloring, you will notice that the wax quality is substantially softer and thicker than Crayola. 

You will notice that if you make more layers with RoseArt crayons, more residue is produced, and it’s lumpy, making the colors darker.

Another thing you will notice is that there are small flakes of foreign colors mixed in it, unlike Crayola crayons where you consistently get the same color every time.

<strong>RoseArt</strong>
Pros
  • Very affordable price
Cons
  • Produces more residue
  • With color impurities
  • Color transfer
  • No washable version
  • Brittle
  • Limited colors
<strong>Crayola</strong>
Pros
  • Good packaging
  • Sturdy
  • Consistent colors
  • Wide variety
Cons
  • Slightly expensive

FAQs

Is Crayola better than RoseArt?

When it comes to RoseArt crayons vs Crayola crayons, Crayola is absolutely superior. However, as mentioned, not all RoseArt art materials are inferior.

You will get better results with some specifically for colored pencils, where the RoseArt color range is more attractive than the colors under Crayola.

RoseArt watercolors and markers’ quality and colors are apparently close to their superior counterparts.

Is RoseArt still around?

Yes, if you are curious about them and want to try their art and school supplies, you can still find RoseArt’s range of crayons, colored pencils, markers, and watercolors in Walmart or in Amazon.

They also have their own online shop where you can find different RoseArt products other than art materials such as toys and dolls. 

Do professional artists use Crayola?

Yes. Although Crayola is a famous brand for kid’s art supplies, many professional artists use it for their artworks.

There are even crayon artists who solely used Crayola as their medium rather than using other, more professional brands out there.

Are RoseArt crayons non toxic?

Yes, RoseArt is very clear about that. Since the government health and safety issue on crayons was raised in 2000, both RoseArt and Crayola ingredients were reviewed and scrutinized for having carcinogenic raw materials.

By then, RoseArt has put much effort into removing toxic components to improve the quality and make its products safer.

Up to now, all their crayons have been declared non-toxic and free of carcinogens like asbestos and talc.

Conclusion

Generally, RoseArt art supplies are not that bad in terms of quality. In my personal opinion, they were just put in a bad light since they are considerably cheaper than Crayola.

Yes, Crayola is a good brand but based on our comparison of Crayola vs RoseArt art supplies, you will see some spots where RoseArt shines. These are their watercolors and colored pencils.

However, when it comes to crayons, they can’t beat Crayola and RoseArt still has a bunch of things to fix on the formulation side. Still, considering its price, RoseArt is not a bad choice.

5/5 - (2 votes)